Article Outline and Summary: The Textbook Industry and Textbooks (Chall & Squire 1996)
- Outline History of the Textbooks and Basal Readers in the United States:
- No dates listed – New England Primer was the first widely distributed primer.
- Prior to 1775 – Primers emphasized religious text.
- 1778- Noah Webster publishes his American Spelling Book.
- 1775 to 1825 – Primers emphasized religious text and secular text equally.
- 1808 to 1810 – Samuel Wood produced first graded readers. Heavily religious and practical.
- 1825 to 1875 – Primers emphasized moralistic and secular values.
- 1836 & 1844 – McGuffey Eclectic Readers published. Emphasis on moralistic content and phonetic/alphabetic content. 122 million copies sold 1836 to 1920.
- 1875 to 1915 – Primers emphasized literary values.
- 1915 to present – Various emphases including the common “realistic experience.”
- 1920’s – Start of reading reading readiness and pre-primers.
- 1920’s – Scientific research “furthers the form of basal readers.”
- 1920’s – Leveling of texts becomes a concern as more students with less-educated parents attend high schools.
- 1921 – Thorndike Teacher’s Word Book provides objective measurement tool for leveling texts.
1939 – William S. Gray and Scott Foresman write the Elson-Gray Readers (Dick and Jane). 200 Million Americans learned to read with these.
- 1940’s – Schools begin to promote by age rather than achievement, creating a leveling problem for textbook creators.
- Mid 1960’s – 18 Publishers were producing K-8 Reading basal Readers, which were used by more than 85% of elementary teachers.
- 1970’s – Calls for accountability resulted in increased emphasis on test preparation in Basel programs.
- 1970’s and 1980’s – Increased direct instruction
- 1970’s and 1980’s – Development of programs designed for low income children and for minorities.
- 1970’s and 1980’s – Textbooks include more stories about minority characters.
- 1980’s – There were 12 national publishers of basal reading programs.
- 1980’s – The top five publishers sold 80% of basal reading programs.
- Characteristics of the Textbook Market in the U.S. (1986 & 1987):
- 40 Large Textbook Publishers
- $2 billion in textbook sales (converts to $3.8 billion in 2008 dollars)
- 11% of all textbooks were purchased in California
- 7.3% of all textbooks were purchased in Texas
- Highest per pupil textbook spender was Washington D.C. at $68 (converts to $127 in 2008 dollars) per student.
- Lowest per pupil textbook spender was the Great State of Utah at $19 (converts to $35 in 2008 dollars) student.
- 21 states were doing state wide textbook adoptions.
- $436 million (converts to $820 million in 2008 dollars) spent on reading programs for elementary students.
- $600 million (converts to $1.2 billion in 2008 dollars) spent on reading programs, spelling programs, and all other programs and textbooks used for literacy instruction.
- I admit that 1986 and 1987 were a long time ago. I’d like to see what the current statistics look like today. I’d like to if spending trends compare with the rate of inflation?
I didn’t find the rest of the article to be very interesting as it cites a lot of very old studies on textbook features and how they related to student comprehension. I’d rather spend my time reading more current research.
Chall, J.S., & Squire, J.R. (1996). The publishing industry and textbooks. In R.Barr, M. L. Kamil, P. Mosenthan, & P. D. Pearson (Eds.), Handbook of reading research (Vol. 2, pp. 46-67). (Original work published 1991)

